Researchers from the University of Wollongong, Australia, argue that slow-moving hot rock deep in Earth's mantle helped carve the Great Unconformity, a gap in the geologic record visible in the Grand Canyon. Nicolas Flament and Santosh Dhungana describe the gap in a recent Nature study. Its bottom layer is ancient crystalline rock, and its top layer is sandstone laid down during the Cambrian explosion. The gap ranges from about 200 million years to more than a billion years, Flament said.

According to the study's models, mantle convection pushed continents up for hundreds of millions of years. Glaciers then eroded the raised land, and the continents later sank, allowing new sediment to bury the eroded surface. Flament said the team tested this idea, called dynamic topography, which had been proposed before but not quantitatively tested.

The researchers ran six simulations of mantle convection going back 1 billion years. Five of the six models showed Laurentia, the ancient core of North America, rising and then sinking during the Cambrian. Four models showed the same pattern for northern Europe and North China.

Flament said the uplift alone was too gentle to remove enough rock. He argued that glaciers working on the gentle uplift supplied the rest of the erosion. He added that the two processes were not coupled and only overlapped in time. Flament also acknowledged uncertainty. The starting configuration of the simulations remains uncertain, and the magnetic records used to constrain them show continental latitude but not longitude.