Jane, a Canadian writer in her 30s, sought a rare 1990s documentary about the Library of Congress, "Memory and Imagination," using private torrent trackers. She said she wanted to "share it with other people to help ensure it would be preserved into the future." She could not find the film on streaming services, YouTube, pirate sites, eBay, or any public library in North America. She eventually found a DVD at the Bibliotheca Alexandrina in Egypt. She later bought a copy from a small online marketplace for historical media and uploaded it. She described the copy as "a digital rip of a severely degraded VHS tape."
The report describes private trackers as invitation-style communities that trade media through BitTorrent. They rely on secrecy, exclusivity and strict community rules. Their focuses range from broad catalogs to niche categories such as Chinese movies, motorsports and Frank Zappa music. Users who fall below required metrics can lose download privileges, and serious violations can lead to permanent bans.
Access is hard to get. According to the report, some trackers open sign-up only every few weeks or months. Some require proof of good standing on other trackers, screenshots of personal media collections, or interviews. The report says users often work up through lower-tier trackers to reach more exclusive ones. Jane said she maintains active accounts on 14 private trackers. Odel, a college student, said he initially wanted better access to video games. Maysay, a user from Pakistan, said exclusivity is part of the appeal.
Jane said she is "ethically conflicted about piracy" and often feels guilty about it. All the users quoted in the report used pseudonyms because of the copyrighted material they have shared.