The most striking detail in this report is not the list of possible successors. It is the admission that Nvidia has no apparent succession plan for a company valued among the world's most important, and that its chief executive has confessed to an extramarital affair without making clear with whom. A board that allows a company of this size to reach this point has a governance problem that no parlor game can solve.

The report's own reporting shows how murky the situation is. Alice Huang is described as a Chinese executive suspected by U.S. intelligence of spying for her country, while Kimberly Powell, an Nvidia executive who reports to Huang, was named by five sources to The New York Times as a paramour. Those are serious allegations, and the report presents them as allegations. Readers should keep that distinction intact rather than treating the speculation about replacements as settled news.

The candidates the report lists are interesting on their own terms. Lisa Su, Eric Schmidt, Lip-Bu Tan, Bret Taylor, Ian Buck, Andrew Bell and Lori Huang each have a stated record, and the report's own skepticism about several of them is sensible. Schmidt, the report notes, would bring his own baggage around extramarital relationships, and Su's company stands to benefit from Nvidia's distraction. A successful transition will depend less on résumé glamour than on whether the board can explain how it reached its decisions.

The board should answer several questions in public before any new name is announced. It should say what it knew about the relationships involving its executives, when it learned it, and how those relationships intersect with the company's government briefings and its handling of sensitive technology. Investors and the officials who oversee national security reviews are entitled to those answers, especially where the report describes an investigation and congressional attention.

Replacing the chief executive is not the same as fixing governance. If the directors who made Huang wealthy are reluctant to remove him fully, that reluctance should be examined rather than assumed to be prudent. The next step should be a documented succession process with a named interim leader, clear disclosure rules for executives' personal conduct, and an independent review of what the company's controls did and did not catch.