At least 10 local governments and police departments have moved since summer to curb, restrict, or end their use of Flock Safety technology, according to TechCrunch. The report links the moves to growing concerns about mass surveillance and data privacy.
Flock sells surveillance products, including license plate readers, drones, and microphone-based devices that detect gunshots. More than 100,000 Flock cameras are in use nationwide, according to the report.
The report names Monroe, Ohio; Newburgh, New York; Richmond, Virginia; Hopkinton, Massachusetts; New Bedford, Massachusetts; and Lansing, Michigan, as places that moved in the past three months to end their Flock contracts. It also says police in East Bridgewater and Grafton, Massachusetts, announced plans to stop using the cameras. In League City, Texas, residents voted against their police department's continued use of Flock's license plate readers, and the cameras are set to be removed.
The report describes several concerns. These include privacy, how data is shared and with whom, and procurement. It cites a Brentwood, Missouri officer who was accused of using Flock cameras to stalk his ex-wife, and an East Texas officer who was sentenced to prison for using Flock to stalk his ex-girlfriend and her family.
The report also cites a March resolution from Ithaca, New York, which said there were "proven instances" of federal agents using Flock data without specific authorization from the contracting locality. The resolution said the city had reviewed reports that Flock had allowed U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement and the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives to use query results from its database to investigate immigrants.
Flock responded in a statement that removing its tools "moves public safety backward." The company said customers own their data and control how it is shared. It also said Flock does not sell data and does not have a contract with ICE. In August, Flock said it would shorten its default data retention period for new customers from 30 days to seven, and that agencies must now enter a case code before searching the database.
Adam Schwartz of the Electronic Frontier Foundation told TechCrunch that police departments often adopt Flock with little oversight from city councils. In South Windsor, Connecticut, local reports said Flock cameras went live last year without public warning or a vote, and the town voted in October to remove them.